Like many people, I have for years switched back and forth between numerous note-taking applications. The services and applications I've used over time include, but are not limited to:
- Plain text
- Apple Notes
- Canvas (my own startup, now shut down)
- Dropbox Paper (whose infrastructure I worked on for a year)
- Notational Velocity
...and many more.
For the last couple of years, I have switched back and forth heavily between Notion and Bear. I appreciate how Notion looks on the desktop and am interested in its powerful database features, but prefer the way that Bear lets me organize and reference topics. For the past few months, it's become clear to me that the winner (for me) is Bear for the forseeable future. In this post, I'm going to talk about why I enjoy taking personal notes in Bear, and what I would change if I were writing my own app, again.
A Daily Log
The root of my note taking is a simple, mostly linear daily log. For each day, I create a new note and begin appending tasks, relevant thoughts, and relevant events to the log. Generally if I have a meeting, I won't create a new note for it, but will add notes in a nested list:
There's nothing particularly novel here—I have a log per day and keep a list of notes for that day.
In order to make these daily logs easy to peruse, however, I make use of one of Bear's most powerful features, its hashtags (and particularly their ability to be nested). For each week (beginning on Monday), I use a hashtag such as
#log/2020/06/29, where the final day segment is the start of the week for that log's day.
Although Bear can sort tags by date created or modified, I find it helpful to be able to also scope them down to a span of time that I care about.
Since I organize my daily logs using nested tags, I can peruse them by each subsection of that tag—all logs, all logs for the given year, all logs for the given year/month, or all logs for the given year/month/week-start. I find this really helpful for focusing on specific timespans when doing things like writing my self-reviews at GitHub.
Contexts and Pages
The next main category of organization that I employ in Bear is what I call "contexts". Contexts allow me to reference a thing of a specific type, and to easily browse all notes that reference that thing. In addition, pages give me the ability to keep a "home" page for every thing that needs it in Bear.
The context that I use the most is the "projects" context. In the screenshots of the daily log near the start of this article, you'll see references to "X Project" and "Y Project". The first time I reference any of these projects, I do a couple of things:
I begin referencing them by a tag, such as
I create a new home page for that project with basic information.
Now, I have a tag which lets me reference that project in any note (and gives me the ability to find any note where I referenced that project). Additionally, it gives me a home page for that project where I can keep general information about it. Frequently, these pages are where I keep lists like who else is working on the project, what all of the relevant issues, pull requests, pieces of documentation are, and sometimes links to Slack conversations.
The second context I use heavily is the "people" context. Whenever I mention someone in my daily log—for example, because I had a meeting with them or spoke to them on Slack about something—I do the same thing that I do for the projects context: I create a tag for that person that I then use to refer to them, and also create a home page with basic information (generally this is only their GitHub username).
I should also note that for a long time, I was uncomfortable with this. It felt like I was keeping a creepy collection of people in my personal notes. Over time, though, I realized what a huge help it is when I have to write reviews for others. It really improves the quality of those reviews when I can easily refer back to conversations we had and projects we worked on together without having to rely entirely on memory.
Bear has excellent tag autocompletion, so to refer to this person in my notes, just typing
#Ad[TAB] is sufficient.
Building a Habit
So far, I've found this system to be incredibly helpful. It's possible to create something similar in Notion, but it requires joining databases and a huge amount of manual labor that I couldn't keep up with. Except for some minor friction, I've found it easiest to keep a daily logging and note-taking habit with Bear.
You may notice that I haven't used Bear's ability to link directly to another page in this. That feature is something that I rarely use, because contexts essentially do the same thing—it'll be very easy to quickly find the "home page" for a given project amongst its tags, or I just look in the sidebar for all of my project pages. Likewise, linking directly to another page doesn't allow me to easily build a network of cross-linked topics (this is something Roam does, but I didn't enjoy the experience of taking notes in Roam).
If I were building a personal note-taking app again, I think that I'd employ a very similar model to Bear, but I have a few specific improvements I would make in mind:
The most important change I might make would be some automation—I create a home page for the majority of tags that I create with my context system, and so having that done automatically would be really helpful.
I would also love to be able to create tag synonyms. At GitHub, some people are referred to by their "real" name, and some like to be called by their GitHub handle, and some go back and forth. Ideally, I would be able to keep both as viable hashtags for that person, so if I were mentioning myself, I could either use the tag
#people/GitHub/Jonathan Clem# or something short like my actual GitHub handle,
That's just for organization, though. There are a huge amount of changes to the editing experience I would make, but I'll save those for another time!